Classic NY Cookie Box

Classic NY Cookie Box

$35.00
Skip to product information
Classic NY Cookie Box
  • Classic NY Cookie Box
  • Classic NY Cookie Box
Classic NY Cookie Box

Classic NY Cookie Box

$35.00

🇮🇹 Classic NY Cookie Box

Bring home the taste of a real New York Italian bakery.

Our Classic NY Cookie Box is a hand-selected assortment of classic Italian bakery cookie favorites, made in New York by the same bakery locals have trusted for generations. This is the kind of box you’d bring home on a Sunday morning—perfect with coffee, family, and a little nostalgia.

Each box contains:

• 1/4lb Assorted biscotti

• 1/4lb Rainbow cookies

• 1/2lb Italian butter cookies

• 1/4lb S-Cookies 

Every item is baked fresh in NY and carefully packed to arrive ready to enjoy. Whether you’re gifting, hosting, or just craving that authentic up-north bakery experience, this box delivers the real deal.

Why you’ll love it:

• Authentic New York Italian bakery desserts

• Baked fresh in NY

• Small-batch, family-made quality

• Perfect for sharing, gifting, or freezing for later

From the crunch of biscotti to the richness of rainbow cookies and the melt-in-your-mouth butter cookies, every bite tastes like it came straight from the neighborhood bakery.

Limited weekly batches available. Once they’re gone, they’re gone until the next pick-up.

You may also like

Customer Reviews

Overall rating: 4.8 / 5 from 4 reviews.

No photos. The cookies are already in our bellies. Fabulous selection. Zero complaints from any of us. Not a dud in the box. Loved them all!

Melanie M. 5/5 Verified

Classic NY Cookie Box

I am from North Babylon Long Island NY. I have been here in the south for over 20 years . People here just dont understand the yearning we have for a good Italian Bakery. Well I got my first otder from you today and I was thrilled and I plan to be a regular customer. Thank you so much. Ann Marie Elsis

Ann Marie E. 5/5

Classic NY Cookie Box

When I saw this, I got very nostalgic for the Italuan pastries I enjoyed while in New York. I was very pleased to be able to satisfy my longing for the real thing. Our northern friends enjoyed them with us at a celebratory dinner ghe next day. Ronnie hand delivered my cookie box to The Humbke Cup in Fort Mill. Thanks also for the walk down memory lane.

Pat P. 5/5 Verified

Classic NY Cookie Box